Berkeley, West Highland or Sloan's Lake: How to Choose

Pick the right one of these three and the house search gets short. They share a street grid and touch at their borders, and they are three different markets. Here is what each one gives you, and the questions that settle it.

What do you get in Berkeley?

Tennyson Street and two lakes. Berkeley runs from Federal to Sheridan and from 38th Avenue to I-70. The Tennyson Street Cultural District sits between 38th and 46th. Berkeley Lake Park is 83 acres around a 34-acre lake, and Rocky Mountain Lake Park is at 46th between Federal and Lowell.

The houses are bungalows, Denver Squares and brick Tudors from the streetcar decades, next to scrapes and pop-tops that doubled or tripled the original footprint on the same lot. There is no historic district here, which is why the scrapes happen. So Berkeley is two markets on one street. The original stock and the rebuilt stock price differently, appraise differently and appreciate differently.

Walkability here is a function of how close you are to Tennyson. The neighborhood's Walk Score is 82. At 4300 Tennyson it is 95. East of Lowell it drops fast, and the price reflects it.

What do you get in West Highland?

32nd Avenue within walking distance. West Highland runs 29th Avenue to 38th, Sheridan to Federal. It is the one people mean when they say Highlands. The center is Highland Square at 32nd and Lowell: small rooms, long tenures, almost no chains. Coffee, dinner, wine, cheese and pizza happen on foot from most addresses between Perry and Irving.

The stock is Queen Anne Victorians from the 1880s and 90s, Denver squares, and 1900s to 1920s bungalows with front porches. The Packard's Hill historic district protects a pocket of the finest Victorian stock. Renovation quality is the whole game. Many of these houses have been opened up two or three times since the eighties, and a glossy kitchen can hide a hacked floor plan.

West Highland trades at a premium to Berkeley and has kept it. Prices separate at 38th, so check which side your comps sit on.

If Tennyson is a night out, 32nd is a Tuesday.

What do you get at Sloan's Lake?

The water and the mountain view. The neighborhood runs Sheridan to Federal, 17th Avenue to 29th, with the lake in the middle. The loop is roughly two and a half miles. Sunrise over downtown, sunset over the Front Range. No swimming: the lake is for boating, paddling, rowing and fishing.

The lake sets the price. Views and proximity command a premium that falls off fast as you move north. The stock splits by shore:

  • East, toward Federal. 1890s Victorians, early 1900s squares, and 1920s brick bungalows.

  • North and west. Postwar ranches and Tudors on wider lots.

  • South shore. The new chapter, built after St. Anthony Hospital left in 2013.

A large share of recent inventory is the half-duplex, and build quality varies between developers. If you are paying for a rooftop view, confirm the next project over cannot build it out. And check the county line. Cross Sheridan and you are in Edgewater, a separate city in Jefferson County.

How do I choose between them?

Four questions narrow it faster than touring.

  • Which street do you want to walk to? Tennyson, 32nd, or the lake loop. If you will not walk, you are paying for something you do not use.

  • Old house or new house? Character and maintenance travel together. A 1924 bungalow and a 2022 build are two different ownership experiences, and neither one is wrong.

  • How much land do you want? People overestimate this. A small yard in Berkeley is a real limitation. Decide whether you will resent it.

  • Where do you have to be on a weekday? Where you physically go, how often, and at what hour.

Then send me both addresses. I will tell you which one is in the better market rather than which one is the better house. Those are different questions, and only one of them shows up in the photos.

The full guides are here: Berkeley, the Highlands and Sloan's Lake. When you have a number and a short list, Text Heidi or Book a call.

Previous
Previous

Pop the Top or Move: What a Second Story Takes in Denver

Next
Next

Off-Market vs. Coming Soon: What Each One Gets You